AultCare’s Prime Time Health Plan 5-Star Plans in Ohio for 2024

Aultcare Broker Communication 10/18/23:


PrimeTime Health Plan Earns a 5-Star Rating AGAIN!

Empower yourself with great news you can use as we kick off the Medicare Annual Enrollment Period (AEP)! PrimeTime Health Plan (PTHP) has once again achieved an excellent rating of five out of five stars from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). This is the third year in a row that we have received this prestigious designation, and the fourth year overall.

Why a 5-Star Rating Is Important

CMS assigns ratings each year to help Medicare-eligible individuals compare Medicare Advantage and prescription drug plans. Earning the highest rating possible is a result of our team’s dedication to quality of care and quality of service, which helps our members to live better, healthier lives.

Additional Enrollment Opportunity

Because of our five-Star Rating, we can market, and you can sell our plans throughout 2024.

Please contact your PrimeTime Health Plan sales representative if you have questions or need additional information.

AultCare’s PrimeTime Choices Med Supp – Extended Guarantee Issue Update!

Great News Agents!

Aultcare’s PrimeTime Choice Medicare Supplement plans has exteneded their guaranteed issue through the end of 2023!

Please see below for important updates pertaining to PrimeTime Choices:

  • Guarantee Issue will be extended through 2023.
  • Rate increases will be announced by June 1.
    • Letters will be sent to members 30 days prior.

Not contracted with Aultcare? Let us know… we can help! Connect with our contracting department to get started –

AultCare’s Medicare Supplement Guaranteed Issue Extended thru 6/30/23

AultCare Choices extends Guaranteed Issue Medicare Supplement until end of June 2023 with an effective date no later than July 1, 2023.

Med Supp Guaranteed Issue Advantage
Through July 1, 2023 effective dates, AultCare offers clients to move from Plan F to Plan G from any carrier or within the PrimeTime network and anyone coming from an existing/active Plan C supplement plan will receive the Guaranteed Issue to downgrade to Plan G, M or N.

PLUS! Enrollment app enhancements….
A new PrimeTime Choices Enrollment Application is available with upgraded features that mirror the current Medicare Advantage submission process. The enhancements include:
• Single submission for both member and broker information, eliminating the need for brokers to submit a separate form.
• Attachments can be included with your submission
• A progress gauge
• Ability to print the completed application before submission
• A confirmation message when the submission process is complete


Get started today! AultCare PrimeTime Choices

For 35 years, AultCare has provided quality healthcare at an affordable cost to the Ohio communities it serves, state-wide for the PrimeTime Choices Medicare Supplement Plan.

Cornerstone Senior Marketing offers our broker partners the exclusive opportunity to contract with AultCare and offer their plans as a significant part of a well-rounded product portfolio.





Questions?  Contact your Sales or Service Rep to discuss the benefits of adding AultCare to your product portfolio.  614-763-2255

Update on AultCare PrimeTime Health Plan 2023 Sales Materials

Aultcare PrimeTime Health Plan Broker Bulletin from 10/5/2022:


The Annual Enrollment Period (AEP) starts next Saturday, October 15, 2022 and we have an important announcement pertaining to our 2023 materials.


Due to the Inflation Reduction Act, changes needed to be made to our 2023 marketing materials to reflect the correct information. Because of this, there will be a delay until our 2023 are available. Our team is working diligently to finalize and print these items for you to reference throughout AEP.


In the interim, please use the below presentation to assist your clients with their questions about PrimeTime Health Plan’s 2023 Medicare Advantage Plans.  Once the star-ratings are released, this will also be updated and submitted to CMS for approval.

Aultcare PrimeTime Health Plan 2023 MA Plans Presentation


If you have any questions- please reach out to your CSM Service Rep.

AultCare: New Payment Option for Prime Time Members

Sourced from AultCare Broker Bulletin on 12/29/21:

We are excited to announce a new, convenient payment feature for Primetime Health Plan and PrimeTime Choices’ members. As of Dec. 15, 2021, we implemented automated payment phone lines members can call to check their balance and make payments.


As you share this information with members, please advise them they will need to have their member ID number, date of birth, and zip code readily available. Acceptable forms of payment are Mastercard, Visa, and Discover. The phone numbers are listed below.


PrimeTime Health Plan 330-286-6067
PrimeTime Choices 330-286-6068

AultCare Med Supp News for 2022

AultCare Broker Bulletin from 10/20/21:

Good afternoon Brokers,

As the end of 2021 draws near, we have decided to continue to allow downgrades to our Plan G through 5/31/2022.

When we announce information regarding 6/1/2022 renewals, we will also share our plan moving forward on the downgrades.



If you have any further questions or concerns, please reach out to your CSM Representative!


AultCare: New Website Launch!

AultCare Broker Bulletin from 9/30/21:


AultCare is launching a new website, and this is your exclusive sneak-peek!


Launching in early October, our new comprehensive website will give customers access to the healthcare information and education they need.


We are proud to introduce a website that will bring many enhancements, including:

  • A clean, simplified look
  • Easy navigation
  • Properly categorized content
  • User-friendly features

Before the website goes live, please note the following:


  • To access information specific to Brokers, click on the ‘Broker Resources’ link in the main navigation on the Home Page.
  • To log into your Broker Portal, click the white ‘Account Login’ button in the upper right corner and select ‘Broker’ from the drop-down menu. Then, log in with your user name and password like usual.
    • Your user name and password will be the same. They will not change.
  • If you have any AultCare webpages bookmarked, those shortcuts will still work once the new site is launched.


A similar communication will be sent to our employer groups.

We are excited to offer this new resource to our customers. We know this will improve your experience with us digitally!




Introducing AultCare PrimeTime Health Plan




Cornerstone Senior Marketing is excited to share we have another great asset to bring to your clients in Ohio.

For 35 years, AultCare has provided quality healthcare at an affordable cost to the community it serves.

AultCare offers Medicare Advantage plans in the Northeast part of Ohio and also a state wide Medicare Supplement Guaranteed Issue plan.

*MS Guaranteed Issue Advantage*: Through the end of 2021, AultCare offers clients to move from Plan F to Plan G from any carrier or within the PrimeTime network!

Their Medicare Advantage plans service in the select NE Ohio counties:
Carroll, Columbiana, Harrison, Holmes, Mahoning, Medina, Portage, Stark, Summit, Trumbull, Tuscarawas, Wayne.

More great benefits for selling AultCare MA plans:
• Access to their own network, Aultman Medical Group- a network of more than 240 local providers!
• A 4.5 Star Rating for 2021
• Insulin savers program and telehealth for Dermatology coming for 2022

CONTRACTING & CERTIFICATON: 2022 Certification Opening Soon!
AultCare can contract agents once 2022 certification is available.
Interested in getting contracted? Click on the request button below and we’ll notify you once 2022 certification is open and contracting is available.






Questions? Contact your Sales or Service Rep to discuss the benefits of adding AultCare to your product portfolio.

Contact Jaime Lebrón